+

LIVE AUCTION!

YOU HAVE THE POWER!!! To Bid on this Massive MOTU, McFarlane DC Figure, Vintage Video Games and Comic Auction.

Bid Now!

The Ins & Outs of
Collectibles Evaluation

Don't Sell Yourself Short!

Evaluate Your Collection Today!
Step 1:

Tell Us What You Have

Step 2:

Let's Discuss Your Goals

Step 3:

Optimize Your Collection For Top $$$

Get Started

Turn Your Comics and Toys Collection Into Cash

You will not find a better place to buy, sell, or trade...

Without a doubt, the best at what they do. You will not find a better place to buy, sale, or trade. Bottom line is they are good honest knowledgeable people. They put you first, you can rest assured you're in good hands.

Chris C. - Detroit, Michigan

I can't thank you enough. You guys did an amazing job...

I cannot say enough good things about this place. Everyone I dealt with was great, and they made the entire process as easy and convenient as possible. I had to empty my aunt's house after her passing and took a lot of things to Back to the Past. They were amazing and took about 80% of what I had packed up and made me a fair offer. I had initially looked into having a company come out to the house to appraise and make an offer, but those places were not even close to being as helpful or fair. I would recommend Back to the Past to anyone looking to sell collectibles or just declutter their home.

Heather S. - Ann Arbor, Michigan

They’ve got just about everything...

As their name implies, they’ve got just about everything. From comic books to action figures, sports cards, movie reels, rare posters, and everything in between, they are a pop culture lover’s paradise. I’ve spent many hours online going through all the items, finding treasures I couldn’t find anywhere else.

Kalani T. - Detroit, Michigan

These guys were very knowledgeable…

I recently sold a collection of action figures that I have been holding onto for 40 years. These guys were very knowledgeable and paid me top value for my collection. More than I was expecting for sure.

Mike G. - Flint, Michigan

Variety of items is unmatched…

Back to the Past Collectibles always excites me! Browsing their online store and auctions has become my favorite way to escape boredom and discover new treasures. The variety of items is unmatched, and I always find something unique to add to my collection. The staff is incredibly helpful and friendly, even online. Keep up the fantastic work!

Dean S. - Southfield, Michigan

Staff communicated frequently and clearly with me throughout the process…

I recently partnered with Back to the Past to sell a collection of mine from my college years. I had a fair amount of emotional attachment to my collection, but I hadn't touched it in years. Scott did an excellent job of working with me to give me a realistic expectation of its worth as well as helping me to approach the sale without brushing aside the nostalgia aspect. He and his staff communicated frequently and clearly with me throughout the process. In the end, the auction even surpassed my expectations. Scott and staff are friendly and easy to work with - I absolutely will use Back to the Past again and recommend them to everyone!

Edward A. - Cleveland, Ohio

We feel you all went WAY above and beyond...

We feel so blessed we found you all when we did and had no idea what a wonderful experience it would turn out to be. We were especially impressed with the care and thoughtfulness taken in making sure our precious collections were handled and transported with the greatest of ease. We appreciate your willingness to come all the way out to our home and pack everything so carefully for transport. We know this took extra time and effort, and we are truly grateful for your kindness. You handled it like a well-oiled machine, and we will sing your praises to anyone who will listen!

Julie M. - Jacksonville, Florida

Thank you very much...

Thank you very much for your careful packaging of my recent purchase. I appreciate the extra time you took to package my item and ensure it arrived in great condition. It is now one of my favorite pieces in my collection.

Heather H. - New York, New York

Such reasonable shipping and handling rates...

Thanks for charging such reasonable shipping and handling rates. In this day and age of skyrocketing shipping rates, it is so good to do business with a company that tries to keep their shipping rates affordable.

Betsy R. - Katy, Texas

A breath of fresh air from an auction company...

Thank you for combining shipping on the items I won from your latest auction. Your prices are reasonable, and the packaging was done professionally. Such a breath of fresh air from an auction company!

Robert H. - Jefferson City, Missouri

Very knowledgeable staff and easy to work with…

I contacted Back to the Past Collectibles on a whim to see if they would be interested in buying some of my collection. I was helped right away and even without an appointment the gentleman looked at my stuff and with no haggling at all came to an agreement. Very knowledgeable staff and was easy to work with. Would definitely recommend and seeing for yourself.

Andrew F. - Lansing, Michigan

4 stars to you and your crew...

I’m giving high praise today, 5 stars to you and your crew for making a last minute decision easy. I will definitely recommend you to others.

Denise C. - Tampa, Florida

This is how online auctions should be run!

Some of the highest bid prices for special items I’ve ever seen. I was quite impressed! Thanks again for such an amazing experience. Online auctions should be run like this!

Michael H. - Tulsa, Oklahoma

The customer service is A+ above and beyond…

I have just found Back to the Past Collectibles recently .... and I am very impressed and pleased by the service they provide. They have some of the coolest stuff up on auction. The packing is immaculate, thank you for a great job! And I am sure all others that package orders do a great job as well. The customer service is A+ above and beyond! I will check out future auctions and will definitely recommend Back to the Past Collectibles to my friends!

Denise W. - Chicago, Illinois

I love your auctions...

I love your auctions. I hope you have many more! Thanks for bringing these rare and great items to market. I enjoy the bidding process and have found some really cool things! Keep up the fantastic work!

Lisa M. - Antioch, Tennessee

I love Back to the Past so much...

I love Back to the Past Collectibles so much because of the employees. Even online, they’re always so friendly and helpful. They go above and beyond to help me find what I need and always strive to give me the best deals. I truly appreciate their patience, understanding, and expertise. They really know their stuff!

Greg H. - Garden City, Michigan

Always an adventure browsing your online store…

It’s always an adventure browsing your online store. There’s always a lot of new goodies to choose from and buy. It’s refreshing to know that you hold a multitude of treasures for each and every customer to discover and find!

Kenny R. - Wixom, Michigan

I love following their newsletters…

The breadth of knowledge that the employees here possess is staggering! I love following their newsletters and learning something new each time I get one. Plus, on their online auctions there’s always something new and different to find and buy. Great job with the auctions!

Jim H. - Farmington, Michigan

They made payment and pickup very easy…

Back to the Past bought a collection of toys that my brother and I had been holding on to since childhood. It was a wide range of toys from the 70s, 80s, and 90s and Pete (from Back to the Past) was very knowledgeable about all of them. They provided a fair offer and were very reasonable when we wanted to hold on to a couple of items for nostalgia. They made payment and pickup very easy as well, taking the whole collection (even things that had little to no value) so it was all taken care of by the time they were done. I would highly recommend them for anyone in a similar situation.

Christopher N. - Westland, Michigan

Your business became my hero...

I just want to say thank you again for helping me navigate what was a difficult situation. Your kindness and compassion during a rough time for me was so very appreciated. Your business became my hero of the day!

Eric R. - Nashville, Tennessee

My absolute favorites to buy from...

Back to the Past is my absolute favorite place to buy comics and collectibles. Your staff is very knowledgeable and the selection is always top notch. Your customer service is excellent and your prices are always reasonable. Thanks for all the hard work you put into making this such a great place to shop online!

Matt L. - Lansing, Michigan

Truly a treasure trove where deals abound...

I had a wonderful experience selling some of my things! The employees were kind and easy to talk to! They have lots of space, always willing to take in new items to sell! Great way to make extra money! The store is always clean! Great variety of items! Employees always helpful. Love going there to look at the variety of things. I love my collection of items from out of state (got to collect some treasures from different states!). Back to the Past really is 'truly a treasure trove where deals abound'!

Laurie F. - Grand Rapids, Michigan

Back to the Past is the best overall experience…

In the last 2-3 years, I’ve explored comic and toy stores all over the United States. But Back to the Past Collectibles stands out as the best overall experience, even online! I can’t wait for more of your auctions and to continue finding treasures through your site. Thanks to everyone for doing such a great job with all the online auctions. I’m looking forward to the next one!

Mike H. - Modesto, California

You will not find a better place to buy, sell, or trade...

"Without a doubt, the best at what they do. You will not find a better place to buy, sale, or trade. Bottom line is they are good honest knowledgeable people. They put you first, you can rest assured you're in good hands."

- Chris C. - Detroit, Michigan

I can't thank you enough. You guys did an amazing job...

"I cannot say enough good things about this place. Everyone I dealt with was great, and they made the entire process as easy and convenient as possible. I had to empty my aunt's house after her passing and took a lot of things to Back to the Past. They were amazing and took about 80% of what I had packed up and made me a fair offer. I had initially looked into having a company come out to the house to appraise and make an offer, but those places were not even close to being as helpful or fair. I would recommend Back to the Past to anyone looking to sell collectibles or just declutter their home."

- Heather S. - Ann Arbor, Michigan

They’ve got just about everything...

"As their name implies, they’ve got just about everything. From comic books to action figures, sports cards, movie reels, rare posters, and everything in between, they are a pop culture lover’s paradise. I’ve spent many hours online going through all the items, finding treasures I couldn’t find anywhere else."

- Kalani T. - Detroit, Michigan

These guys were very knowledgeable…

"I recently sold a collection of action figures that I have been holding onto for 40 years. These guys were very knowledgeable and paid me top value for my collection. More than I was expecting for sure."

- Mike G. - Flint, Michigan

Variety of items is unmatched…

"Back to the Past Collectibles always excites me! Browsing their online store and auctions has become my favorite way to escape boredom and discover new treasures. The variety of items is unmatched, and I always find something unique to add to my collection. The staff is incredibly helpful and friendly, even online. Keep up the fantastic work!"

- Dean S. - Southfield, Michigan

Staff communicated frequently and clearly with me throughout the process…

"I recently partnered with Back to the Past to sell a collection of mine from my college years. I had a fair amount of emotional attachment to my collection, but I hadn't touched it in years. Scott did an excellent job of working with me to give me a realistic expectation of its worth as well as helping me to approach the sale without brushing aside the nostalgia aspect. He and his staff communicated frequently and clearly with me throughout the process. In the end, the auction even surpassed my expectations. Scott and staff are friendly and easy to work with - I absolutely will use Back to the Past again and recommend them to everyone!"

- Edward A. - Cleveland, Ohio

We feel you all went WAY above and beyond...

"We feel so blessed we found you all when we did and had no idea what a wonderful experience it would turn out to be. We were especially impressed with the care and thoughtfulness taken in making sure our precious collections were handled and transported with the greatest of ease. We appreciate your willingness to come all the way out to our home and pack everything so carefully for transport. We know this took extra time and effort, and we are truly grateful for your kindness. You handled it like a well-oiled machine, and we will sing your praises to anyone who will listen!"

- Julie M. - Jacksonville, Florida

Thank you very much...

"Thank you very much for your careful packaging of my recent purchase. I appreciate the extra time you took to package my item and ensure it arrived in great condition. It is now one of my favorite pieces in my collection."

- Heather H. - New York, New York

Such reasonable shipping and handling rates...

"Thanks for charging such reasonable shipping and handling rates. In this day and age of skyrocketing shipping rates, it is so good to do business with a company that tries to keep their shipping rates affordable."

- Betsy R. - Katy, Texas

A breath of fresh air from an auction company...

"Thank you for combining shipping on the items I won from your latest auction. Your prices are reasonable, and the packaging was done professionally. Such a breath of fresh air from an auction company!"

- Robert H. - Jefferson City, Missouri

Very knowledgeable staff and easy to work with…

"I contacted Back to the Past Collectibles on a whim to see if they would be interested in buying some of my collection. I was helped right away and even without an appointment the gentleman looked at my stuff and with no haggling at all came to an agreement. Very knowledgeable staff and was easy to work with. Would definitely recommend and seeing for yourself."

- Andrew F. - Lansing, Michigan

4 stars to you and your crew...

"I’m giving high praise today, 5 stars to you and your crew for making a last minute decision easy. I will definitely recommend you to others."

- Denise C. - Tampa, Florida

This is how online auctions should be run!

"Some of the highest bid prices for special items I’ve ever seen. I was quite impressed! Thanks again for such an amazing experience. Online auctions should be run like this!"

- Michael H. - Tulsa, Oklahoma

The customer service is A+ above and beyond…

"I have just found Back to the Past Collectibles recently .... and I am very impressed and pleased by the service they provide. They have some of the coolest stuff up on auction. The packing is immaculate, thank you for a great job! And I am sure all others that package orders do a great job as well. The customer service is A+ above and beyond! I will check out future auctions and will definitely recommend Back to the Past Collectibles to my friends!"

- Denise W. - Chicago, Illinois

I love your auctions...

"I love your auctions. I hope you have many more! Thanks for bringing these rare and great items to market. I enjoy the bidding process and have found some really cool things! Keep up the fantastic work!"

- Lisa M. - Antioch, Tennessee

I love Back to the Past so much...

"I love Back to the Past Collectibles so much because of the employees. Even online, they’re always so friendly and helpful. They go above and beyond to help me find what I need and always strive to give me the best deals. I truly appreciate their patience, understanding, and expertise. They really know their stuff!"

- Greg H. - Garden City, Michigan

Always an adventure browsing your online store…

"It’s always an adventure browsing your online store. There’s always a lot of new goodies to choose from and buy. It’s refreshing to know that you hold a multitude of treasures for each and every customer to discover and find!"

- Kenny R. - Wixom, Michigan

I love following their newsletters…

"The breadth of knowledge that the employees here possess is staggering! I love following their newsletters and learning something new each time I get one. Plus, on their online auctions there’s always something new and different to find and buy. Great job with the auctions!"

- Jim H. - Farmington, Michigan

They made payment and pickup very easy…

"Back to the Past bought a collection of toys that my brother and I had been holding on to since childhood. It was a wide range of toys from the 70s, 80s, and 90s and Pete (from Back to the Past) was very knowledgeable about all of them. They provided a fair offer and were very reasonable when we wanted to hold on to a couple of items for nostalgia. They made payment and pickup very easy as well, taking the whole collection (even things that had little to no value) so it was all taken care of by the time they were done. I would highly recommend them for anyone in a similar situation."

- Christopher N. - Westland, Michigan

Your business became my hero...

"I just want to say thank you again for helping me navigate what was a difficult situation. Your kindness and compassion during a rough time for me was so very appreciated. Your business became my hero of the day!"

- Eric R. - Nashville, Tennessee

My absolute favorites to buy from...

"Back to the Past is my absolute favorite place to buy comics and collectibles. Your staff is very knowledgeable and the selection is always top notch. Your customer service is excellent and your prices are always reasonable. Thanks for all the hard work you put into making this such a great place to shop online!"

- Matt L. - Lansing, Michigan

Truly a treasure trove where deals abound...

"I had a wonderful experience selling some of my things! The employees were kind and easy to talk to! They have lots of space, always willing to take in new items to sell! Great way to make extra money! The store is always clean! Great variety of items! Employees always helpful. Love going there to look at the variety of things. I love my collection of items from out of state (got to collect some treasures from different states!). Back to the Past really is 'truly a treasure trove where deals abound'!"

- Laurie F. - Grand Rapids, Michigan

Back to the Past is the best overall experience…

"In the last 2-3 years, I’ve explored comic and toy stores all over the United States. But Back to the Past Collectibles stands out as the best overall experience, even online! I can’t wait for more of your auctions and to continue finding treasures through your site. Thanks to everyone for doing such a great job with all the online auctions. I’m looking forward to the next one!"

- Mike H. - Modesto, California

Understanding Your Toys and Comics Collection

Everything has Value, but Concentrated Value = Higher Outcomes

Composition Matters

The Gems Drive the Value of the Entire Toy collection

Even everyday items can carry value but when it comes to your collection, it's often the hidden gems that make the biggest difference. Key issues, limited runs, rare variants, and mint-condition items are the drivers that elevate your entire set. Knowing which pieces pack the most punch helps determine your collection's full potential and how best to bring it to market.

Let's Review Your Composition

Understanding how the market works

And how it plays a pivotal role in the ultimate value of your comic collection

The collectibles market is always moving, what's hot today might cool tomorrow. Timing, demand, rarity, and trends all play a role in what your items are worth at any given moment. Our team keeps a close pulse on the market, so you don't have to. We'll help you understand where your collection fits and when the right time to sell might be.

Let's Review Your Collections Value

Best Ways to Gut a Toys and Comics Collection

Usually with Best Intentions this is the Most Painful Mistake People Make with Their Collection

Picking Out Key Items Individually Can be Costly

Don't Find Out You've Made a Mistake After it's Too Late.

An Unpicked Comic Collection

$70,000

A Gutted Comic Collection

$32,000

Your Toy Collections Value Really Depends on Your Goals

Are you in a hurry?

Need to sell now?

Timing is critical

Timing takes on two rolls:

  • Timing Market Trends
  • How quickly you want to sell the other items

Timing plays a roll in:

  • When to sell
  • The venues we use
  • Go to market strategy

Gain Access to Strategic Markets and Platforms

Getting top dollar isn't just about what you sell, it's where and how you sell it. From live auctions to private buyers to online spotlights, we tailor your go-to-market strategy based on what will work best for your unique collection. With our reach and know-how, we'll connect your items with the collectors who are already looking for them.

Get Started!

Sell Your Vintage Memorabilia for More Money!

Let's Chart a Path to Top Value

Why Should I Get My Vintage Memorabilia Collection Evaluated? 

Every item holds a story, and understanding their worth goes beyond just curiosity. Here are a few reasons why understanding the value of your possessions is important when selling your collection:

We understand the sentimental and financial value your vintage collections hold. Let our team of memorabilia experts guide you through the process! 

Contact Our Team

Estate and Probate: When the time comes to distribute family heirlooms, it's not just about a "pile of stuff." Knowing the true value ensures equitable outcomes for descendants. After all, one "pile" might hold treasures surpassing the next.

Financial Planning: While financial advisors often inquire about real estate, stocks, and bank accounts, they sometimes overlook the hidden gems. In our experience, comic book, toy, and movie material collections can rival or surpass the value of a home. Get the full picture of your net worth by including collectibles in your financial plan.

Insurance Protection: Safeguard your treasures with the right insurance plan. Most insurance companies require expert evaluations to accurately back the collection. Whether a ballpark estimate suffices, or a detailed line-by-line review is necessary, we've got you covered.

Planning for Downsizing: Anticipating a future downsizing? Determine what items might be sold, donated, or even disposed of. An orderly process, given time to unfold, yields

Bringing in Something New: Have your tastes or interests changed recently? Maybe your collection at one point sparked joy but you’re ready to shift your attention to something new? It happens all the time. Many clients have partnered with us to sell their current collection, paving the way to a fresh start.

Sell your Toys & Comic Collection with True Market Evaluations from Back to the Past Collectibles

At Back to the Past Collectibles, we bring decades of experience to every evaluation, ensuring that you not only discover the stories behind your items but also unlock their maximum value.

Our dedicated team of experts prides themselves on providing transparent, fair, and market-value evaluations, allowing you to make informed decisions about your valuable collectibles. Our marketing team will take over from there, finding just the right buyer for your collection.

Get Started!

Understanding go-to-market Strategy

Get Started!

Frequently Asked Questions About Evaluating Vintage Collectibles

How do you evaluate a comic book?

Uncovering the value of a comic book comes down to identifying the exact printing and establishing the books’ condition. Variations in publication date and condition will have a big impact on the value. With the right information locked in, then researching sold prices will tell us what the current market rate is on that comic! Ask us and we’ll put our expertise to work and get a precise dollar value for your collection.

What determines the value of a comic book?

The value of a comic book is a tapestry woven with factors such as rarity, condition, age, and the character or story arc featured – often referred to as a "key" issue. Comics showcasing beloved characters like Wolverine or Spider-Man tend to hold greater value. There is so much to know, it can become complicated so contact Back to the Past Collectibles to help you understand the intricacies of your collection.

How are sports cards evaluated?

To unveil the value of your sports cards, you need to know the exact printing or issuance of the card itself and then grading the card for its condition. Better cards should be submitted for professional grading by a company like PSA! At any point in this process, our experts at Back to the Past Collectibles can provide a comprehensive evaluation, ensuring you receive the true worth of your prized cards.

How do you price sports cards and memorabilia?

We determine the value of your sports cards and some memorabilia with precision by considering factors such as the quality of the signature, rarity of the item, historical importance of the player, and the confidence in its authenticity. At Back to the Past Collectibles, we guide you through this process to ensure your signed items are priced accurately.

Do signed sports cards increase in value?

For sports icons like Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and Michael Jordan, their autographs often maintain or increase in value over time. We recognize the worth of these signatures, making them highly sought-after by collectors willing to pay a premium.

How do I find out how much my vintage memorabilia item or collection is worth?

By making sure you have identified the exact items you have and their conditions and then using tools to look up true “sold” values (not the same as a seller’s asking price!). Connect with our experts at Back to the Past Collectibles to receive a personalized evaluation. You'll gain a comprehensive understanding of your collection's true worth.

Does vintage memorabilia go up in value?

The value of vintage memorabilia fluctuates with market rates, influenced by various factors. While economic downturns may decrease costs, there are additional elements to consider when determining the price of a particular object. Overall, many collectible items have beaten the stock market at appreciating value over the years!

How do you evaluate a coin collection?

A coin collection can be a fun hobby, but it can also be a valuable investment into precious metals like silver and gold. If you’re thinking of selling your collection, or if you just want to get an idea of its value, you should take your coins to an expert in coin valuation, like Back to the Past Collectibles where we’ll give you an honest assessment of your collection’s worth.

How do I prepare for a coin evaluation?

Preparing for a coin evaluation is straight forward. If the coins are in albums or page holders, avoid removing them, keep the books intact. If coins are loose or in individual slips, then it can be helpful to organize by type and date. Avoid handling with bare hands as the oil can deface coins in better grade. This organization ensures a smooth and accurate evaluation process.

How do I sell coins?

Coins can be sold straight to a dealer or organized into a live auction event. It depends on the circumstances and goal of the coin seller. We’re always available to discuss options and guide the sale to the best market outcome, so check in with Back to the Past Collectibles when you are ready to investigate selling your collection!

How much does it cost to have a coin collection evaluated?

A basic idea of the price of a pile of coins might be quick and free. For deeper line-by-line evaluations, the price will be determined on a per-hour basis to get a comprehensive listing of values. It’s important to have an evaluation done so that you can be sure of the value of your collection in case you ever need to sell it or insure it against loss or damage, but it’s just as important to understand your end goal so the evaluation can meet your needs.

How do I get my coin collection evaluated?

You can have the coins in your collection assessed by Back to the Past Collectibles, just ask us! We’ll make an appointment to sit down and get your collection evaluated by looking at each coin and assessing its value.

How long does it take to get a coin evaluated?

This depends on the size of the collection and the exact goal of the evaluation. At Back to the Past Collectibles, we can evaluate coins within minutes. However, rare, or unusual coins or extensive collections may require additional time for a precise evaluation.

It’s Time to Discover What Your Vintage Collection is Worth 

Whether you’re ready to sell today, tomorrow, or well in the future, we’ll help you understand the value of your collectibles so you’ll be prepared when the time comes. Contact our team to get started!

Contact Us

Don’t Miss a Thing - Subscribe to Our Newsletter!

Don't miss out on any exciting developments — subscribe to our newsletter today to receive updates delivered directly to your inbox!